Buddha 346

Transmigration of Life

King Milinda questions to Venerable Nāgasena: “Venerable Nāgasena, does rebirth take place without anything transmigrating?
Nāgasena: “Yes, O King. rebirth takes place without anything transmigrating.
King Milinda: “Give me an illustration, Venerable Sir.
Nāgasena: “Suppose, O King, a man were to light a light from light pray, would the one light have passed over to the other light?
King Milinda: “Nay, indeed, Venerable Sir,
Nāgasena: “In exactly the same way, O King, does rebirth take place without anything transmigrating.
King Milinda: “Give me another illustration.
Nāgasena: “Do you remember, O King, having learnt, when you were a boy, some verse or other from your teacher of poetry?
King Milinda: “Yes, Venerable Sir.
Nāgasena: “Pray, O King, did the verse pass over to you from your teacher?
King Milinda: “Nay, indeed, Venerable Sir.
Nāgasena: “In exactly the same way, O King, does rebirth take place without anything transmigrating.”
Again King Milinda questions:
“Venerable Nāgasena, what is it that is born into the next existence?
Nāgasena: “O King, it is mind and body that is born into the next existence. “It is this same mind and body that is born into the next existence?
Nāgasena: “O King, it is not this same mind and body that is born into the next existence, but with this mind and body, O King, one does a deed – it may be good, or it may be evil – and by reason of this deed another mind and body is born into the next existence.
King Milinda: “Venerable Sir, if it is not this mind and body that is born into the next existence, is one not freed from one’s evil deeds?
Nāgasena: “If one were not born into another existence, one would be freed from one’s evil deeds but, O King, in as much as one is born into another existence, therefore is one not freed from one’s evil deeds.
King Milinda: “Give me an illustration.
Nāgasena: “O King, it is as if a man were to take away another man’s mangoes, and the owner of the mangoes were to seize him, and show him to the king and say – ‘Sire, this man hath taken away my mangoes’; and the other were to say, ‘Sire, I did not take away his mangoes. The mangoes which this man planted were different from those which I took away. I am not liable to punishment.’ Pray, O King, would the man be liable to punishment?
King Milinda: “Assuredly, Venerable, Sir, he would be liable to punishment.”For what reason?
Nāgasena: “Because, in spite of what he might say, he would be liable to punishment for the reason that the last mangoes were derived from the first mangoes. “In exactly, the same way, O King, with this mind and body one does a deed – it may be good, or it may be bad – and by reason of this deed another mind and body is born into the next existence. Therefore is one not freed from one’s evil deeds.”

6 Responses

  1. venkateswarlu

    sir, these sotries and material posted are educative.I like this type of lucid language and good examples and explanations reach the mass and educate and make the reaers to think and practise the dhamma with proper understanding
    May all beings be happy
    with metta

  2. venkateswarlu

    sir, these sotries and material posted are educative.I like this type of lucid language and good examples and explanations reach the mass and educate and make the reaers to think and practise the dhamma with proper understanding
    May all beings be happy
    with metta

  3. venkateswarlu

    sir, these sotries and material posted are educative.I like this type of lucid language and good examples and explanations reach the mass and educate and make the reaers to think and practise the dhamma with proper understanding
    May all beings be happy
    with metta

  4. venkateswarlu

    sir, these sotries and material posted are educative.I like this type of lucid language and good examples and explanations reach the mass and educate and make the readers to think and practise the dhamma with proper understanding
    May all beings be happy
    with metta

  5. venkateswarlu

    sir, these sotries and material posted are educative.I like this type of lucid language and good examples and explanations reach the mass and educate and make the readers to think and practise the dhamma with proper understanding
    May all beings be happy
    with metta

    • Atmabodhi

      Thanks Venkates for your kind words & appreciation. Our mission is to help readers to gain the self wisdom & dhamma through the stories.